November 23, 2011 - Updated on January 20, 2016

Court refuses to free Ergenekon case journalists, adjourns until end December

The trial of 10 journalists accused of involvement in the ‘Ergenekon’ anti-government conspiracy
began yesterday in the Istanbul district of Caglayan with the court rejecting a defence request for
their immediate release and then adjourning until 26 December.

Lawyers representing some of the journalists, including Soner Yalçin, also requested the
replacement of the court’s president on the grounds that he had already convicted them in
another media case. The request will be considered another court under Turkey’s criminal
procedure law (CMK).

Many local and international media attended the news conference held yesterday morning
by press freedom organizations including Reporters Without Borders at the initiative of
Turkey’s “Freedom for Journalists” coalition (GÖP).

Most of the representatives of these organizations, including Reporters Without Borders,
Human Rights Watch, the Helsinki Citizens Assembly and the Turkish Journalists Association
(TGV), were unable to attend the first part of the hearing because the courtroom was too small for a trial of this

The presiding judge’s decision to ban observers who did not have seats was greeted with
protests from the activists. The ban was lifted in the afternoon.

When the next hearing is held on 26 December, investigative journalists Ahmet Sik and Nedim
will have spent 10 months in prison and Soner Yalçin will have been held for 11 months


22.11.2011 Two leading investigative journalists go on trial today

The trial of investigative journalists Ahmet Sik and Nedim Sener on a charge of participating in an
anti-government conspiracy opens today in Istanbul. Oda TV news website owner Soner Yalçin
and eight of his journalists – news editor Baris Terkoglu, managing editor Baris Pehlivan, news
coordinator Dogan Yurdakul and reporters Müyesser Yildiz, Coskun Musluk, Sait Cakir and Yalçin
– are also being tried with them.

Reporters Without Borders has travelled to Istanbul to attend the first hearing as part of an
international delegation that includes representatives of the European Parliament, the European
Federation of Journalists, the International Press Institute, and the European Journalists’ Association, invited by Turkey’s “Freedom for Journalists” coalition (GÖP).

“We are here as a reminder of the attention we are paying to this trial,” the head of the Reporters
Without Borders Europe Desk, Johann Bihr, said shortly before it got under way in the Istanbul
district of Caglayan. “We have already come to Istanbul twice this year to express our concern
about the wave of arrests of journalists and our solidarity with them. But no positive step has
been taken despite the unprecedented protests in Turkey and aboard. Instead the arrests have
resumed and now we are angry.

“Ahmet Sik, Nedim Sener and their eight colleagues have been held for the past month although
there is no evidence against them. Ragip Zarakolu, a leading publisher and independent
journalists has been held for the past three and a half weeks despite his age and health. Other
journalists such as Tuncay Özkan, Baris Açikel and Vedat Kursun have been held for years.
Some of them are still awaiting trial. This is intolerable.

“As for the 10 journalists on trial today, the prosecutors had promised to produce hard evidence
to justify their pre-trial detention. Where is it? Contrary to what was always claimed, the case
against them is based on their work as journalists. They are being tried for criticizing the conduct
of the trial of the alleged ‘Ergenekon’ conspirators, and for questioning the judicial system’s
impartiality. Some are being tried for their militant coverage. If the judicial authorities do not free
them at once, they will be responsible for a grave threat to the country’s democratic future.”

Ahmet Sik’s latest book, “The Imam’s Army”, was presented at
the Istanbul book fair on 16 November although the book’s manuscript was seized by the police
during a search on 3 March
and seems to have been the main reason for his arrest. The version
presented by PEN was based on a draft that had been posted online.

Reporters Without Borders secretary-general Jean-François Julliard and Europe desk officer
Johann Bihr were among the 125 people who signed the preface. Reporters Without Borders has
meanwhile joined Turkey’s “Freedom for Journalists” coalition in sending a letter of support to
every imprisoned journalist on the occasion of a current Turkish festival.

It is time Turkey ended the serious abuses of which journalists are among the leading victims.
Arrests of journalists have been marring the democratic model that Turkey aspires to
embody. Reporters Without Borders issued an investigative report in June about the Ergenekon
case, which is at the heart of many of the current political and media controversies.